Janmashtami stories
Why Is Janmashtami Sometimes on Two Days? Smarta and Vaishnava
Ask AIBy the Dharmasthan team · Updated · 4 sources cited
Janmashtami is sometimes listed on two days because traditions use different rules. Smarta calendars, following digests like the Nirnayasindhu, take the day whose midnight falls in Ashtami; Vaishnava calendars prefer the Ashtami present at sunrise and avoid one touched by Saptami.
At a glance: Janmashtami
- Tithi
- Shravan Krishna Ashtami at midnight (Bhadrapada Krishna Ashtami in North India’s purnimant calendar), about a week after Raksha Bandhan: the eighth tithi after its full moon
- Worship of
- Krishna, with Devaki, Vasudeva, Nanda and Yashoda
- Also known as
- Krishna Janmashtami, Gokulashtami (Maharashtra), Krishnashtami, Krishna Jayanti
Ashtami, Rohini and midnight
The texts on Janmashtami look to three things: the tithi Ashtami, the eighth day of the dark half; the nakshatra Rohini, which they prize but do not require; and midnight, the hour of Krishna’s birth. P. V. Kane sums up the Puranas: the principal time for the festival is the midnight of the dark eighth of Shravan, or Bhadrapada in the purnimant months, with or without Rohini (History of Dharmaśāstra, vol. V, p. 134).
The three rarely line up neatly. A tithi does not begin at sunrise; it can start in the afternoon of one day and end in the evening of the next, and Rohini keeps its own timetable. So the Ashtami may cover midnight on the first day but be over by the second midnight, or Rohini may come a day late. The medieval digests worked through every combination: the Nirnayamrita lists eighteen kinds of Ashtami for this one fast, and Kane judges the debate to be of little more than academic interest to modern readers (p. 134).
The Smarta rule: the Ashtami of midnight
The Smarta rule comes from digests like the Nirnayasindhu of Kamalakara Bhatta, written in 1612. Its ruling is short: “अत्र निशीथवेध एव ग्राह्यः”, the Ashtami that touches midnight is the one to take, because midnight is the time of the rite. It quotes a verse of the Vasishtha Samhita: when Ashtami joined with Rohini is seen at midnight, that is the principal time, for Hari himself was born then.
So a Smarta household fasts on the day whose midnight falls in Ashtami, even if the morning of that day was still Saptami; the Nirnayasindhu quotes a verse that Janmashtami, Rohini and Shivaratri are all kept “पूर्वविद्धा”, on the day joined to the earlier tithi. The Tithitattva, as Kane summarises it, adds the tie-breaks: prefer the day with Ashtami and Rohini together; if that happens on two days, or if Ashtami holds midnight on both days or on neither, take the later day (p. 134).
This is the rule Dharmasthan’s own calendar follows. The digests also show how practice varied: the Nirnayasindhu says the people of its time kept Janmashtami rather than a separate Jayanti fast, while a southern work, the Jayantinirnaya, says people generally keep Jayanti, a difference Kane thinks is probably due to north and south (pp. 132–133).
The Vaishnava rule: the Ashtami of sunrise
Many Vaishnava traditions, ISKCON among them, choose the day differently. They look at the tithi present at sunrise and avoid an Ashtami that is touched by Saptami, keeping the following day instead, the one that begins in Ashtami; when Ashtami holds the sunrise of two days, Rohini helps decide between them. The digests quote a verse of the Brahmavaivarta Purana that points the same way, “वर्जनीया प्रयत्नेन सप्तमीसंयुताष्टमी”, avoid with care an Ashtami joined with Saptami, though the Nirnayasindhu applies it only when midnight does not settle the day.
The difference is old. The Nirnayasindhu itself records that the devotees of Nimbarka took the tithi present at sunrise for Janmashtami, Rama Navami and Shivaratri, and it argues against them. Kane adds that the parana may even be at night in certain cases, particularly for Vaishnavas who keep the vrata as a duty rather than for any reward (p. 139).
When the Smarta midnight falls on the first day and the Vaishnava sunrise Ashtami on the second, calendars list two dates, often a Smarta date and a Vaishnava or ISKCON date a day later. In other years the rules agree and there is a single date. Neither date is a mistake: each follows its own tradition faithfully.
The fast, the midnight puja and the parana
The vrata has four parts, Kane writes: the fast, the worship of Krishna, the vigil through the night with hymns and stories, and the parana, the meal that ends the fast (p. 135). The procedure in the digests, based on the Bhavishyottara Purana, has the devotee take the vow in the morning, bathe at noon, worship the baby Krishna at midnight with Devaki, Vasudeva, Nanda, Yashoda and Balarama, offer water to the Moon when it rises with Rohini, and keep awake until morning (pp. 135–137).
The parana has rules of its own. A verse of the Brahmavaivarta Purana, quoted in the digests, says the fast should not be broken while the Ashtami or Rohini is still running, but at the end of both; the Narada Purana allows it once at least one of them has ended (Kane, pp. 138–139). Usually this means a meal the next morning after the morning worship, but in some years the panchang gives a later time.
For families the practical rule is simple: keep the date your family tradition follows, Smarta or Vaishnava; fast and keep the midnight puja on that night; and break the fast at the parana time your panchang gives.
Aartis and bhajans for Janmashtami
- Vanamali Vasudeva Jaganmohana Radha Ramana
- Aarti Kunj Bihari Ki
- Ankhiyan Hari Darshan Ki Pyasi
- Pag Ghunghroo Bandh Meera Nachi Re
- Shri Radha Kripa Kataksh Stotram
- Jasoda Hari Palne Jhulave
- Mere To Giridhar Gopal Dusro Na Koi
- Shri Krishna Govind Hare Murare
Playlists to read in order or host live
All Janmashtami aartis, bhajans and playlists →Frequently asked questions
Why Is Janmashtami Sometimes on Two Days? Smarta and Vaishnava
Janmashtami is sometimes listed on two days because traditions use different rules. Smarta calendars, following digests like the Nirnayasindhu, take the day whose midnight falls in Ashtami; Vaishnava calendars prefer the Ashtami present at sunrise and avoid one touched by Saptami.
When is Janmashtami in 2027?
Janmashtami 2027 falls on Wednesday, 25 August 2027. Dates are worked out for Mumbai from the panchang; local observance can differ by a day.
On which tithi is Janmashtami celebrated?
Shravan Krishna Ashtami at midnight (Bhadrapada Krishna Ashtami in North India’s purnimant calendar), about a week after Raksha Bandhan: the eighth tithi after its full moon
Which aartis and bhajans are sung on Janmashtami?
Devotees sing Vanamali Vasudeva Jaganmohana Radha Ramana, Aarti Kunj Bihari Ki, Ankhiyan Hari Darshan Ki Pyasi, Pag Ghunghroo Bandh Meera Nachi Re, Shri Radha Kripa Kataksh Stotram. All are free to read on Dharmasthan, with lyrics and meaning.
Sources
- Nirnayasindhu of Kamalakara Bhatta, Pariccheda 2, Janmashtami and its parana (Nirnaya Sagar ed., 1940): Midnight decides (“nishitha-vedha eva grahyah”); Jayanti; the devotees of Nimbarka and the sunrise tithi; parana rules Read the text
- P. V. Kane, History of Dharmaśāstra, vol. V part 1 (1958), pp. 132–139: Janmashtami and Jayanti, the Tithitattva’s rules, the items and procedure of the vrata, and the parana Read the text
- Vaisnava Events Calculation in GCAL (the calendar program behind ISKCON’s Vaishnava calendar), test 1.5.2: The Vaishnava rule: the day with Ashtami at sunrise, with Rohini deciding between two such days Read the text
- Bhagavata Purana 10.3: The birth at midnight with Rohini in the sky (vv. 1–8) Read the text